MATCH OF THE DAY - 1931 COUNTY CHAMPIONS – A TEAM OF FIGHTERS
On 04 April 1931, Sunderland defeated Durham City in the final of the Durham Senior County Cup by 14 points ( 4 tries 1 conversion) to 9 ( 3 unconverted tries). The route to the final came with victories over North Durham (5-0), Darlington (15-5) and Ryton (17-0). The final was played at Blaydon in front of 3,000 spectators. Sunderland players Waterhouse, Spence, Dixon, Bannister and G Cox were later to appear on the club’s Second World War Honours Board and their wartime biographies appear elsewhere on this site. Also, in the side was (Major) James Storey. His father and two uncles had been Ashbrooke members and had outstanding records for the First World War. One of the three was killed in action.* James Storey, who appeared in the 1931 final went on to captain the 1st XV in the mid-1930s. He played 20 times for the county and, as he was a territorial army officer in the mid-1930s too, went on to represent the Territorial Army XV at rugby. During the war, which he survived, he was mentioned in despatches.
The final itself was dominated by City in the early stages although some of their passing was considered ‘wild’. City scored first after a break by McClaren. The conversion was missed. Soon after a slick Sunderland move involving captain H J Nicholson, Dixon and Cox ended with Cox touching down in the corner. This conversion was also missed. Sunderland had another try written of just before City re-took the lead. Thus, the half-time score was 6-3 to City. As in the first half, City started the second half strongly and soon increased their lead to 9-3 with an unconverted try. Sunderland were said to be to blame for too many mistakes and frequent ‘dropped passes’. However, they seized the tie with a period of domination. Eighteen minutes into the second half Alan Marr put down in the corner for an unconverted try. Soon after, an interception led to a try by Cox. Waterhouse’s attempt at a conversion hit the bar. All was square now at 9-9. Minutes later Bain put down near the posts for Sunderland and Waterhouse converted. The score remained at 14-9 at the final whistle.
Among the Sunderland players in the final was Alan Marr who went on to great things in the ship building world. Beside him was E E Carruthers who had an England trail and county players H J Nicholson (12), W B Allan (14), L S Toon (5) and F W Welburn (1). Frank Welburn was a local auctioneer who had learned his rugby at Barnard Castle School. Leslie Toon was educated at rugby-playing Worksop College and later moved to live in West Hartlepool.
All in all, a talented side with Alan Spence the only known victim of the Second World War. It is worth noting that Waterhouse and Cox, who were first cousins, contributed more than half of Sunderland’s points.
See the recent entries on the five WW2 players mentioned above. *Details of the Storey brothers WW1 experiences are in my WW1 online book.





Comments