top of page

MATCH OF THE DAY – ONE OF THE LONGEST LOCAL RIVALRIES

10 minutes ago
6 min read

Today’s league fixture sees the coming together of two of the oldest clubs in the north – Sunderland (1873) and Percy Park (1872). With the added spice of Durham/Sunderland and Mackems/Geordies this has always been a fixture to cherish. The fixture for  Saturday 14 December 1907, for example,  afforded a large advert in the Shields Daily News with admission for gentlemen 3d*, boys 1d and ladies free with an extra 2d for the uncovered stand and 3d for the covered stand . A posh gentleman would  have had to cough up 6d ( modern equivalent about £4) for a cosy seat. The writer of a report of that match noted that Park had won five, Sunderland four with one drawn match over the last ten meetings . The  Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer for January 1904 covered a Sunderland victory at Ashbrooke thus:



Newspaper Report SRFC v Percy Park 1904
Newspaper Report SRFC v Percy Park 1904

This newspaper account features two of the club’s most interesting players.  Both are in the club’s Hall of Fame which I put together a few years back:


Edgar ‘Tegger’ Elliot was a remarkable sportsman. He played his rugby for Sunderland, Durham County, the Barbarians and England. He was capable of playing on both wings and represented England against Scotland, Ireland and Wales in 1901 and against Wales again in 1904. He also made eight appearances for the Barbarians and played in all four games during the 1900/01 tour of Wales. In four of these games his inside partner was also from the Sunderland club. Twice it was Norman Cox (who gained an England cap against Scotland in 1901) and on the other two it was his own brother and centre H R Elliot. An early club history noted proudly that, by the middle of the twentieth century at least, the club had ‘the unique distinction of two brothers providing a complete wing for the famous club (i.e. the Ba Ba’s). ‘Tegger’ played for and captained Durham County and appeared in two county championship finals recording 20 tries in 29 appearances. He was also an outstanding cricketer and in a Durham County history from the 1930s was described as ‘the most brilliant batsman that ever played for Durham’. He also played for Sunderland, for the Minor Counties and the Gentlemen of England. His two games for the ‘Gentlemen’ made him a first-class cricketer. His nickname, apparently, came as a result of a younger brother being unable to pronounce ‘Edgar’.


Phil Clarkson was one of our club’s great characters and has a claim to  real rugby fame. He was the first player to score a try against the All Blacks on British soil. The date was 7 October 1905 and the venue – Durham City’s ground. This was the seventh game of the tour and the visitors had already racked up over 200 points and conceded four.  The match was against Durham County who were national champions at the time and the All Blacks ended as victors by 16 -3 with Phil’s three-point effort coming from the wing.  He was a regular for club and county in the early 20th century and scored seven tries in 17 county outings. He came from a sporting family based in East Boldon. The son of a gentleman ship owner and broker, he worked as a dealer in oils. He is instantly recognisable on team photographs and a contemporary fan recalled him as a player of courage and determination with a wonderful sense of humour. He always had a ‘sly grin’ and was ready for ‘badinage’ with spectators. We are lucky to have a photograph that more or less backs this up!


Two other members of the 1904 Sunderland 1st XV were the unfortunate Nathaniel Clark Neilson and former British Lion Alan Ayre-Smith. Nathaniel Clark Neilson had his birth registered in Tynemouth in the second quarter of 1885. His father described himself as ‘independent’ and in 1891 the family was living at 13, The Esplanade, Whitley Bay. Nathaniel attended Durham School and was in the cricketing 1st XI in 1902.  He was at school at the time of the 1901 census and, soon after, was playing rugby for a successful Sunderland 1st XV and an equally successful Durham County side. He also played rugby for Winlaton Vulcans. He married in Rugby in 1910. By the time of the 1911 census, he was under manager at Chopwell Colliery registered as a mining engineer and living with his wife in North Terrace. During the war, he served in the public-school battalion of the Royal Fusiliers and entered the field of conflict in November 1915. He was killed in action ‘in France’ on 5 February 1916. His grave is in Cambrin Military Cemetery in Northern France and his death (service number 3027) was recorded in The Times on 24 February. He is remembered on the school memorial and there is a photograph of him as part of the 1904/5 Sunderland RFC 1st XV. He gained the 1915 star. He left nearly £2,000 to his wife in probate and she was given £3-6-0 in war gratuity in 1916 and a further £7 in 1919. His parents lived in Alnmouth at some point. Alan Ayre-Smith was born in Sunderland on 19 August 1876 and was destined to become one of the city’s most significant rugby players. His father was a surgeon and although the family home was at 5, Park Terrace, Sunderland in 1881, Alan and his siblings were at Cotherstone in Teesdale at census time. Here they were described on the census return (amusingly and unusually), by the enumerator as ‘Dr Smith’s children’. From 1889 to 1892 Alan attended Dulwich College and in 1891 was living in London with his parents. He studied for science degrees at Durham University before training in medicine at Guy’s Hospital. He played rugby for Guy’s and in 1899 was invited to take part in what is now regarded as the British Lions’ first tour – to  Australia. Ayre Smith played in 17 of the 20 tour matches and represented Britain in all four Test Matches against Australia. He scored his only international try in the second test and played an important part in the victories achieved in the third and fourth tests. He then sacrificed his international rugby career and travelled to South Africa where he worked as a dresser in the Imperial Yeomanry Hospital during the Boer War. By 1902, he was back in Sunderland where he played for the 1st XV for three seasons. In the first season, the team won the county cup and in the last, he served as 1st XV captain. He was also part of a successful Durham County side during the same period. He then turned his attention to volunteer soldiering as surgeon lieutenant with the 1st Durham Garrison Volunteers and served there from 1905. In 1908 he became part of the new Royal Garrison Artillery. Married in 1908, he was a captain in the R.G.A. when the war broke out. By now he was in his late 30s. He served as captain and major in the Royal Army Medical Corps attached to the local R.G.A. He entered the Western Front on 3 March 1916 and claimed his medals in 1922 from 15, Grange Crescent. In 1914, his club membership has his address at 7, Grange Crescent. He died in 1957 at the age of 81.


It is worthy of note that today’s match of old rivals is matched over the next two weeks by Ryton (1880) and Durham City (1872). Good for all concerned!!!!


Tegger Elliot (middle front)
Tegger Elliot (middle front)
Phil Clarkson - Quite a character!
Phil Clarkson - Quite a character!

P.S. I have just discovered a newspaper report on a match between SRFC and Park which took place on 24 September 1892 – a game which Park won 9-8.  The Northern Echo reporter noted:


Sunderland had hard lines once or twice. That sterling player W H Bell showed much of his old dash and energy and along with Howard Marshall played a good passing game.


Howard Marshall had already played for the Barbarians and the British Lions and a few months later scored a hat-trick for England against Wales in Wales!!! At the time of the Percy Park match, he was about to return to his medical studies having spent the summer with his family in the Elms.

 
 
 

Comments


Ashbrooke Sports Club, West Lawn, Sunderland SR2 7HH.  Registered Charity 1087978

©2023 by Ashbrooke Sports Club. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page